You are on an individual archive page

Click here to return to the main page


Wikipedia does good things. Reward them.

The Daily Links Page
Got a link to submit?
  • New Evidence Proves First Flag Made By Betsy Ross Actually Shirt For Gay Friend
  • Colbert Leads Huntsman in S.C.
  • Polish prosecutor 'shoots self after news conference'
  • Jim Rome leaving ESPN. Bonus: Footage of Jim Rome getting attacked by Jim Everett & crying like a baby
  • Broncos, Tim Tebow stun Steelers in OT, win 29-23 in NFL playoffs
       [ 2 comments ]
  • Video: Remember 2008
       [ 1 comment ]
  • Beezow Doo-Doo Zopittybop-Bop-Bop faces weapon and drug charges
  • Video: Green Bay anchorman loves lamp
  • Video: Rodgers & Raji in the new Discount Double Check ad
  • Jim Rome: out of The Jungle and onto the (horse) farm
  • New IL Law Requires Photo ID To Buy Drain Cleaner
  • Fawn Cuddles Kitten, Hearts Explode
  • The priest who changed the course of history for the worse... by rescuing four-year-old Hitler from drowning in icy river
  • Get Fit or Get Fined: Web Service Offers to Charge You for Skipping the Gym
  • Fine proposed for botching US national anthem
  • Why Best Buy is Going out of Business...Gradually
       [ 1 comment ]
  • Edina boutique takes heat for trashing $4,000-plus gowns
  • Law Student Goes 'Homeless by Choice' Touts Value of Gym Club Membership
  • VIDEO: Snoop Dogg on 'The Price Is Right'
  • Flynn and Out
       [ 3 comments ]
  • Don't put Bielema on the firing line
       [ 1 comment ]
  • Your end of the season Vikings comment thread
       [ 2 comments ]
  • Mass. budget motel fights forfeiture by feds
  • Vikings scrutinize downtown Mpls. stadium site near basilica
       [ 2 comments ]
  • Kelly Clarkson criticized on Twitter after singer endorses Ron Paul for President 
  • Political Predictions for 2012
  • We're All Doing The Best We Can
  • Video Of Little Girl Getting Pissed Off About Pink Toys Will Make Your Heart Swell
  • The 10 best sports-related Hitler Reactions of 2011
  • Happy Endings on the housing crisis
  • Why You Just Got New York Times Spam
  • There Will Be No Friday This Week In Samoa
  • The Most Hipster State In The US
  • Online Merchants Home in on Imbibing Consumers
       [ 1 comment ]
  • On islamic fashion
       [ 1 comment ]
  • Sears as Lampert's 'Mismanaged Asset' Loses Customers to Macy's
       [ 1 comment ]
  • 5 social network predictions for 2012
  • Cheetah, chimp star of classic Tarzan movies, dies at 80
  • The Hottest Things on TV in 2011
  • Beer in cans: It's not just for Bud anymore
  • Seven Packers earn Pro Bowl selections
  • The Worst Angry Christmas Tweets In the World
       [ 2 comments ]
  • Minnesota cities try to hold back on rented housing
  • Why Iowa Shouldn't Vote First Anymore
  • Some Falcons Players Upset Drew Brees Went For The Record Last Night
  • We've Identified Jilted Packergirl
  • With its 'W' initiative, ESPN tries to solve the equation of serving women sports fans
       [ 2 comments ]
  • Owner surprised to find cat regularly catches bus
  • Charles Barkley: Skip Bayless Has Surpassed Peter Vecsey As The Biggest Jackass In The History Of Journalism
  • Handicapping the 2011 NFL MVP Race, 2.0

     

  • Four Letter Words

       August 15, 2005

    I was thinking today about two four letter words that have been in the news lately: "Gaza" and "Kelo".

    The Supreme Court's ruling in Kelo v New London was roundly panned. People on the left and the right were appalled that a person's home could be taken from them for a potential economic benefit.

    Today Israeli settlers in Gaza are being forcibly removed from their homes with little such outcry. Rather than dwell on the losses being inflicted on those individuals, we're sold a different story:

    While the withdrawal from Gaza has long been demanded by Palestinians, it is in Israel's interest as well. It will free up Israeli soldiers who have been devoted to the defense of far-flung clusters of Jewish housing surrounded by hostile Palestinians. It is a rational response to the demographic challenges that threaten to leave Jews a minority unless Israel loosens its hold on the West Bank.

    I wonder why the individual homeowners in New London are treated like tragic heroes, while Gaza settlers are labeled "extremists" and "hard-liners". To me, there are a hell of a lot of similarities going on here (ignoring for a moment that Gaza settlers don't have the US constitution to appeal to). In both cases, government is taking something from the individual for some nebulous greater good.

    Of course, it shouldn't be surprising. The same people that wanted to make public policy out of what Terri Schiavo's family said are the same people attacking Cindy Sheehan now. And vice versa. Too many of us are focused on the outcomes we want at the expense of what good government is, so we'll hold up a representative individual to acclaim or scorn, depending on whether we agree with their politics.


    Posted by at August 15, 2005 10:40 PM

        The trackback entry for this page is : http://www.inthehat.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1030

     

    Trackback Entries

     


    Comments

    #  August 15th, 2005 10:56 PM      james
    the "settlers" in gaza were told not to go there. they went anyway. they have a mentality that goes like "oh, the government is just saying that, if we go, we're helping the cause, b/c they can't kick us all out!"

    it's like a group of people knowing full well train fare is $10, but all getting on with only $5 thinking "what, theyre not gonna stop the train and kick us all of!"

    i'm reminded of an acquaintence who bought a house right next to the highway - the house was, of course, cheaper than comparable houses b/c of the noise and location. as soon as he and his neighbors had their cut-rate mortgages locked in, they started petitioning the city to move the highway or build a wall. disgusting.
     
     
    #  August 15th, 2005 11:17 PM      kris
    that's not really what i was talking about. it was more about how we personalize something if we agree with the cause and use emotion in place of logic. And then, we'll turn around and bitch about people using emotion in place of logic when we disagree with the cause.

     
     
    #  August 15th, 2005 11:26 PM      james
    i dont use emotion in place of logic. i think they're all nuts  
     
    #  August 15th, 2005 11:31 PM      kris
    i didn't mean "we" as in you. i meant we as in people in general.  
     
    #  August 16th, 2005 9:30 AM      thegameiam
    Actually, James, for the most part the settlers were encouraged by official Israeli government policies to move and settle there. There were housing subsidies, and a variety of other incentives to do so.

    The change from "the government wants you to move to Gaza" to "the government wants you out of Gaza" took only a few years, and many of the people living there have been there for more than a decade.

    No matter one's feelings on whether this is right, it's hard not to feel sorry for someone who is losing their home.  
     
    #  August 16th, 2005 10:09 AM      james
    i just don't think that's true, thegameiam. i've followed this problem closely, and have not seen one government policy encouraging settlers to move into these areas since at least 1998. (1998 is when i started following it, not when i say it started.) if you have some evidence to the contrary, i'd love to see it.

    israel has a parlimentary government and there are factions that support these "settlers," sure. so what? if nancy pelosi thinks that cows should vote, that doesn't make it "official govt policy." ehud barak's govt came to power in 1999, and it was certainly never encouraged by him, or since then.  
     
    #  August 16th, 2005 12:33 PM      thegameiam
    The settlers I've been reading about have been living in their houses for > 14 years. That places them well before Ehud Barak.

    Also, take a look at this and this and this.

    The thing to notice is that no house can be constructed without explicit approval from the governemnt, and part of what that approval means is tax benefits, etc (don't forget that Israel is still a moderately socialist country, so the government is involved down to the particulars of many things).

    -David  
     

     

     


      page rendered in 0.0367 seconds | ©2004, 2005 Dummocrats.com