A 15 Year Old's Take On The Media and Hurricane Katrina
My daughter and I were watching a reporter in Baton Rouge - Stephanie Something-or-other - on WWL report on how long the power is expected to be out in New Orleans. This Stephanie said that she had discussed it with the experts, with the people responsible for getting the power back on, and they told her that they expected to have it on in 6-8 weeks for most of the metro area. Stephanie then proceeded to say that she just did not see how that was possible given what she has been told by other people reporting on this problem. She spent at least twice as long explaining that the experts were wrong, in her opinion - and even said, I'm no engineer, but I just don't see how this is possible. She offered no evidence whatsoever. Only a vague reference to her chats with other reporters and bystanders.
I asked my 15 year old daughter who is not a regular news watcher if she thought anything was wrong with the report. (We homeschool moms have to try to make a teachable moment out of everything. It's obnoxious, I know.) My daughter replied that she couldn't figure out why the reporter thinks she's smarter than the engineers and experts, and wondered why the reporter was trying to make things seem even worse than they already are.
It's a good question. I still have friends missing. I know quite a few people who have lost everything they owned. A friend's husband fought the battle of the Convention Center and told her that he shot more people in that fracas than in Iraq and Bosnia combined. (What does that say about Iraq, I wonder... somebody page Chrenkoff.) I've read the reports about the looting and mayhem. I've been told that it will be a very long time before I can go home, although I'm not sure I believe that. Will the media ever be satiated with bad news? If this tragedy isn't enough to pacify their hunger, I'm afraid to speculate what would.
Posted by Laura Curtis at September 5, 2005 01:29 AM
The trackback entry for this page is : http://www.inthehat.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1067
| Trackback Entries | |
| Zebrality.com linked with A 15 Year Old's Take On The Media and Hurrica... | |
| ShrinkWrapped linked with The Hostile Dependent Eternal Adolescent | |
| ShrinkWrapped linked with The Hostile Dependent Eternal Adolescent | |
| carts cones drills earplug edger forklift generator goggle heater helmet jointer ladder lathes lopper magnet mask milling parachute planer polisher radio ramps sander shelter solder sprayers torch trolley trowel welding linked with chinaku | |
Comments
| # September 5th, 2005 7:52 AM BrianH |
| Laura,
You're doing a great job teaching that daughter. Keep it up! Many (most?) adults wouldn't have questioned that reporter's abilities. |
| # September 6th, 2005 9:29 AM kris |
| I'd imagine you're getting all kinds of "teachable moments" out of this.
I suspect your daughter's learning more going through this than about 99% of the kids who started school around the country this week. |
| # September 6th, 2005 11:27 AM Laura |
| She's getting a whole new lesson on coping with stress, anyway. From when we told her that we we're leaving and might not have a home to come back to, pack up those things that she loves and cannot be replaced, and can fit in our Saturn, to camping out here at my brothers, watching the news and wondering if any of her friends died, (none so far, but some still unaccounted for) it has been a "growing up" experience. We've been VERY fortunate and she knows that too - she's not whining about all this commotion, she's thanking God we got off so easy and aren't living in the Astrodome. We went to a local church Sunday and ran into another New Orleans family from our church - one of her good friends - who lost everything; their house is still underwater. They're going to stay here permanently. I know I'm biased, but watching her comfort her friend I just thought that she is really growing into a phenomenal young woman - I could not be more proud. |







