Daily Page | Zebrality | NCAA Pool | General Chat | Latest Comments

You are on an individual archive page

Click here to return to the main page


Wikipedia does good things. Reward them.

The Daily Links Page
Got a link to submit?
  • Obama to delay repeal of 'don't ask, don't tell'
  • J.P. Hayes is as honest as we like to think we are
  • Al Franken challenging this ballot
       [ 1 comment ]
  • When you don't want to be Facebook friends
  • Early exposure to peanuts may prevent allergy
  • Suicide evidence likely out of MySpace hoax trial
  • Big Three CEOs Flew Private Jets to Plead for Public Funds
  • A Defense of Wisconsin...From Illinois
  • Gals: Six Tips for Meeting Guys
  • Mitt Romney: Let Detroit Go Bankrupt
       [ 1 comment ]
  • 500G painting rocks Antique Roadshow
  • SEC Charges Mark Cuban With Insider Trading
  • 40 Reasons for Gun Control
  • Christine Todd Whitman and Robert M. Bostock: GOP can't afford to remain hostage to social fundamentalists
       [ 4 comments ]
  • Melvin says Brewers will check in with Sabathia this week
  • The world has never seen such freezing heat
       [ 1 comment ]
  • The battle for Paul Bunyan's Ass??
  • Gay marriage propped on children's show
  • Secretary of State Hillary Clinton?
       [ 1 comment ]
  • Would an Auto Bailout Lead to National Greatness?
  • 5 Myths About an Election of Mythic Proportions
       [ 1 comment ]
  • Dave Ramsey, Peter Schiff, and decline of U.S. Economy
  • Peter Schiff Was Right - 2006 - 2007
  • Kickball, with a dose of beer-infused nostalgia
  • Tolerance fails T-shirt test
  • Franken seeks access to rejected absentees
  • Obama pledges to lead the most open and transparent presidential transition in history, starting by pointing out how carefully worded all his promises regarding lobbyists were
  • Courage: Bravery doesn't mean you're not scared
  • Election of Obama inspires run on guns
  • The onset of ODS
  • Utah: the hate state?
  • Minnesota Ripe for Election Fraud
  • Bankruptcy would be the best thing for GM
  • Nasa Mars mission declared dead
  • Thousands Climb Steps Of Sears Tower For Charity
  • Consider the squirrel
  • CA high school features star power on, off field
  • Government proposing to confiscate workers' personal retirement accounts
       [ 1 comment ]
  • Sales Literature, Exposed
  • Obama Looks to Abandon Poland
  • What We Learned From Week 11 In College Football
  • Now Comes Talk of a Bailout from the Bailout
  • Text of President-elect Obama at a news conference
  • Obama Used Conversion Rate Optimization to Win
  • Report: '08 turnout same as or only slightly higher than '04
       [ 3 comments ]
  • Election Analysis: America Can Take Pride In This Historic, Inspirational Disaster
  • Why Republicans Have Lost Big in Two Straight Elections
  • Tommy Thompson bemoans a blue Wisconsin
  • The List: Which presidential polls were most accurate?
  • A Sweeping Rejection of President Bush

     

  • Putting Ideology Above The Law

       January 17, 2007

    The powers that be in Madison, Wisconsin have decided to embarrass themselves yet again. Upset by the passage of Wisconsin's constitutional amendment to ban gay marriage in November, the Madison Common Council voted last night to "allow elected or appointed officials to protest the ban while taking their oath of office and swearing to uphold the Wisconsin and U.S. constitutions.The approved measure gives officials the option of signing a statement that they took the oath 'under protest'. They can also pledge to fight to overturn the amendment."

    Well that's just dandy. Apparently my elected officials only feel the need to uphold the laws that they personally agree with. Unfortunately for them, upholding state law is an essential part of their jobs. Like pharmacists who don't want to prescribe birth control pills or cabbies who don't want to transport liquor or service animals, I suggest they find a line of work that won't cause their ideology to interfere with their livelihood. If members of the Madison Common Council are so horrified by the new Wisconsin constitution, then I suggest that they resign their positions and devote their political lives to overturning the amendment or at least working to overturn the portion that bans civil unions.

    Supporters of this measure point to the fact that Madison voters overwhelmingly rejected the gay marriage ban and that therefore the city's elected officials are only obeying the wishes of their constituents. That's true, but last time I checked Madison was still bound by Wisconsin law, unless we seceded from the state while I wasn't paying attention. I'm not saying it couldn't happen! Maybe that is the answer. Madison should secede, but not just from Wisconsin, but rather from the entire United States. After all, "we" didn't vote for George W. Bush, why the hell should he be our President? Of course, all of this would necessarily require that we give up state and federal money, so ah, maybe not. Wow, it's hard to be "70 square miles surrounded by reality".

    Maybe I'm looking at this all wrong. Instead of making fun of the Madison Common Council, should I be praising them for their trailblazing ways? Could they be ushering in a whole new era of truth in electoral advertising? If Madison voters know that their elected officials intend to ignore certain laws, maybe other officials will make their intentions clear too. A sheriff or district attorney can run on the fact that he won't arrest or prosecute individuals for underage drinking or speeding or a House candidate can be let it known that she, in fact, is for sale to the highest bidder. This could be the first step toward exactly the kind of transparency we need in government. I take it all back. Thanks Madison Common Council, you're clearly ahead of your time!


    Posted by kris at January 17, 2007 10:52 AM

        The trackback entry for this page is : http://www.inthehat.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1435

     

    Trackback Entries

     


    Comments

    #  January 17th, 2007 6:28 PM      TheUnabrewer
    I'm torn. Seems like a silly place to make a stand, but if some politicians refused to, say, collect taxes, I'd be their biggest cheering sections.

    On a more realistic note, disobeying unjust laws led to the right outcome when it came to Jim Crow laws. So...it can go either way. There's a time and a place for it; the question is whether this is the time and the place. And a lot of people disagree about that.  
     
    #  January 17th, 2007 6:48 PM      kris
    I voted against the Amendment. I completely disagree with it, but I certainly wouldn't equate a gay marriage ban with Jim Crow laws. I think it's rather insulting to do so.  
     
    #  January 17th, 2007 7:25 PM      TheUnabrewer
    My larger point is that I don't automatically hold someone who chooses to disobey a law in disdain.

    I agree that Jim Crow and gay marriage aren't equivalent; after all, gay people can choose to draw up contracts if they so desire and thereby gain rights that blacks in the south never could have.  
     
    #  January 17th, 2007 8:11 PM      kris
    Well actually, Wisconsin's amendment outlawed contracts that mimic marriage too.

    I think the larger point is that Jim Crow laws were unconstitutional and this is a case where the state constitution has actually been changed.  
     
    #  January 23rd, 2007 2:02 PM      thegameiam
    Civil disobedience has an honorable history, and one should follow one's conscience in these matters.

    However, it also has consequences: disobeying the law in a civil manner means being willing to accept the punishment for disobeying the law - think of Rev. Dr. King going to jail, as an example.

    The appropriate course of action would be for them to refuse to take the oath of office, and resign.  
     
    #  January 23rd, 2007 6:29 PM      kris
    Exactly. What these people want to do is have their cake and eat it too. They want to nobly protest something but they're not willing to sacrifice anything for it. That's what offends me.  
     

     

     


    To leave a comment you must be logged in.
    Log in here
    or Get an Account here.